IRA vs 401(k) vs Roth - Part 1

July 17, 2018

I have found that professional, super-smart people, that I personally know, do not know the difference between an IRA, a Roth IRA, and a 401(k). That will simply not do. You need to know this stuff. We’re going to fix that right now. The challenge will be keeping it short and sweet because there are sooooo many things I want to say.

In part 1, we will discuss the differences between IRAs and 401(k)s. Then in part 2, we will talk about the differences in the Roth versions of these same things.

To help illustrate this, we’re going to think of these things as buckets. A bucket holds things. In this instance, the bucket is going to hold money. You want to put your retirement money in one of these buckets. Which one? Well, that depends.

Buckets

Pink Bucket

IRA -- IRA stands for Individual Retirement Account.

Quick History: The IRA was established when Congress passed the ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) in 1974. People LOVED this idea, so another act was passed (the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 or ERTA) to make the IRA available for all workers under 70 ½, and to increase the contribution limit. Different laws increased allowable IRA contributions and caused changes to the tax code through the years but the basic premise is still the same.

Why it came about: At the time, many businesses had pension plans for their employees, but not all did. So, this act created a way for people to save money in their own retirement accounts.

Pros:

  • Available for all people with earned income, including non-working spouses of people with earned income (called a spousal IRA)
  • Individuals can contribute up to $5,500/year (under age 50), and up to$6,500 (for those over age 50)
  • May get a tax deduction for the amount of the contribution

    Jill-splain this: If you make under the threshold of income (changes each year but in 2018, you had to make under $120k Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) if you were single or under $189K MAGI married filing jointly), you may be able to deduct your full IRA contribution on your tax return.

  • IRA contributions are protected in bankruptcy, up to $1,000,000
  • Can name your own beneficiary, avoiding probate court
  • Contributions grow tax-deferred---meaning, that if you earn dividends/interest/have growth on your investment---none of that is taxable to you until you go to take a distribution.
  • Easy to open and you can open one almost anywhere (bank, investment firm, online, etc.)
  • You control the investments, only limited by the options in place where you set up the account.

Cons:

  • Not through employer, so no payroll deduction and you have to remember to make the contributions on your own
  • Can’t contribute past the age of 70 ½ which is when you have to start taking mandatory distributions
  • Can’t take money out until you reach the age of 59 ½ without a 10% penalty (with some exceptions)
  • Distributions are taxable income to you (with some exceptions)
  • Income limitations on the deductibility of contributions (meaning, you are always able to put money into an IRA, but it may not be a tax-deductible contribution)
Yellow Bucket

401(k) – named after the tax code section to which it applies, a 401(k) plan is an employer-sponsored retirement plan.

Quick History: A guy named Ted Benna, who worked for a small consulting firm, designed a plan for his own firm that was essentially the very first 401(k) in 1980. This type of plan caught on like hotcakes and now over 94% of private employers offer them.

Why it came about: Congress passed the Revenue Act of 1978 in order to try to limit high-earning executives from stashing their salary away in cash-deferred plans, thereby avoiding tax.

Pros:

  • Higher contribution limits vs IRA: current limit if you are under 50 is $18,500, or $24,500 if you are age 50 and over
  • Contributions are made pre-tax

    Jill-splain this: Let’s say I make a $30k/year salary. I want to contribute 5% to my 401(k). This means I will contribute $1,500 to my 401(k) over the year. When I get my W-2, instead of box 1 saying I made $30k, it will say, I made $28,500. So when I file my taxes, I will report $28,500 as wages, even though I really made $30k. This makes the $1,500 pre-tax, because I am not paying tax on that income.

  • Protected from bankruptcy, up to a limit
  • Can name your own beneficiary (although there are stipulations that if you are married, your beneficiary has to be your spouse, unless they agree not to be, which, could be awkward).
  • Contributions grow tax-deferred
  • Contributions can be made effortlessly through payroll deduction and changed at any time = easy
  • Some employers offer a matching contribution or profit-sharing contributions
  • May be able to borrow (take a loan out) against your 401(k) if you are in an emergency situation (not recommended, however).

Cons:

  • Only have access to a 401(k) account through your employer so if they don’t offer one, you’re out of luck. However, you can be self-employed and open a 401(k).
  • May not have as many options for investing as you would with an IRA, and the options may not be what you want. For example, you may not be able to buy individual stocks in your 401(k).
  • Your company may have a waiting period--where you have to wait to be eligible to enter the plan
  • Eventually, you have to start taking required minimum distributions.
  • Can’t take money out until you reach the age of 59 ½ without a 10% penalty, if the plan allows this (with some exceptions).
  • Distributions are taxable income to you (with some exceptions)

IRA Blog Graphic

It is important to note, that you can have BOTH a 401(k) and an IRA. A 401(k) is from an employer, whereas you can have an IRA on your own.

So, both of these options are PRE-TAX, and sometimes referred to as “traditional” IRAs or 401(k)s.

I’ll discuss the ROTH tax-deferred option of each of these in next week’s blog.

Any opinions are those of Jill Carr and not necessarily those of RJFS or Raymond James. The information contained in this blog does not purport to be a complete description of the securities, markets, or developments referred to in this material. There is no assurance any of the trends mentioned will continue or forecasts will occur. The information has been obtained from sources considered to be reliable, but Raymond James does not guarantee that the foregoing material is accurate or complete. Any information is not a complete summary or statement of all available data necessary for making an investment decision and does not constitute a recommendation. Investing involves risk and you may incur a profit or loss regardless of strategy selected.

<< Back

How can we help you?

MICHIGAN5206 Gateway Centre, Suite 300 // Flint, MI 48507 //
Phone: 810.732.7411 // Fax: 810.732.8190 //
Map and Directions
FLORIDA712 S. Oregon Avenue // Tampa, FL 33606 //
Phone: 813.251.1879 // Fax: 813.251.1716 //
Map and Directions

Securities offered through Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC. Investment advisory services offered through Raymond James Financial Services Advisors, Inc. Stephens Wealth Management Group is not a registered broker/dealer, and is independent of Raymond James Financial Services. Raymond James financial advisors may only conduct business with residents of the states and/or jurisdictions for which they are properly registered. Therefore, a response to a request for information may be delayed. Please note that not all of the investments and services mentioned are available in every state. Investors outside of the United States are subject to securities and tax regulations within their applicable jurisdictions that are not addressed on this site. Contact our office for information and availability. © Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC | Privacy Policy

Links are being provided for information purposes only. Raymond James is not affiliated with and does not endorse, authorize or sponsor any of the listed websites or their respective sponsors. Raymond James is not responsible for the content of any website or the collection or use of information regarding any website's users and/or members.